Shock over MIL's "inappropriate" request for son's wedding: "Hard no"
A bride-to-be was caught off guard when her future mother-in-law (MIL) asked to renew her own vows at the couple's wedding.
The request, which was made directly to the bride before the groom was even consulted, led to an uproar on Reddit, where users overwhelmingly advised against allowing it.
Strained Relationship
The woman, posting under the username SeniorGood6523, explained that her fiancé has a strained relationship with his mother and stepfather.
According to her, they only reach out when they want something and had not offered to contribute financially to the wedding, despite expecting to use the event for their own celebration.
The MIL justified the request by saying that all five of her out-of-state children would be present, making it a rare opportunity.
The bride-to-be stated that while she is not obsessed with the idea that the wedding must be, 'All about her," she and her fiancé felt like the request was an inappropriate attempt to take advantage of their event, which they were paying for themselves.
The couple also worried that refusing the request would cause a major fight and possibly result in the MIL refusing to attend the wedding altogether.
'Totally inappropriate'
Reddit users were quick to weigh in, with many believing that the MIL intentionally approached the bride first to manipulate the situation.
"Say no! It's totally inappropriate—that is why she called you and not her son to try and manipulate you," one supporter wrote.
Another user took a more direct approach, stating in part, "Hard no", while a fellow critic declared: "Oh lord... me her number and I'll tell her myself how extremely inappropriate that is!"
Many netizens warned that allowing the vow renewal could set a precedent for more demands in the future. Some suggested that if the MIL was truly interested in celebrating with her family, she could plan a separate event rather than attaching it to someone else's wedding.
One person summed up the general mood: "She knows it's wrong. That's why she went to you first instead of her son.
"If she throws a tantrum over being told no, she's proving exactly why you shouldn't say yes."
Expert Advice on Wedding Disputes
Disagreements involving in-laws and wedding planning are common and experts recommend clear communication when tensions arise.
A Brides article on MIL conflicts notes that wedding planning can bring up emotional insecurities, especially when parents feel like they are losing influence over their children's lives.
Licensed therapist Lauren Mollica advised that maintaining a united front as a couple is key when dealing with overbearing parents.
Similarly, Focus on the Family addressed the issue of overstepping in-laws, noting that while empathy for their emotions is important, couples need to be firm in their decisions.
Licensed psychologist Bill Maier suggested that parents who try to control events often struggle with their own anxieties and their demands should not override a couple's right to enjoy their wedding the way they envisioned.
'Crazy to be put in this situation'
The bride-to-be thanked Redditors for their feedback in an update.
"I told my MIL I wasn't comfortable with it," the OP continued.
"She actually reacted MUCH better than expected and admitted after she thought it over, she realized it wasn't appropriate.
"A whole weight has been lifted off my chest. Crazy to be put in this situation in the first place, but thankful it's over."
Newsweek has contacted SeniorGood6523 for comment via Reddit.
Newsweek's "What Should I Do?" offers expert advice to readers. If you have a personal dilemma, let us know via life@newsweek.com. We can ask experts for advice on relationships, family, friends, money and work, and your story could be featured on WSID at Newsweek.
To read how Newsweek uses AI as a newsroom tool, click here.